The Pennsylvania Title Landscape: A Study in Regional Variation

‍

Understanding regional title trends across Pennsylvania is essential for providing clients with accurate time and cost estimations for their potential projects. Dudley Land Company's thorough analysis of these variations helps clients navigate the complexities of title work with confidence and precision.

‍

While not universal, regional title trends appear across the state of PA. These trends are based on many things, including proximity to city centers, the quality of property descriptions, past surface uses, etc. These factors can determine the general complexity of the chains involved and thus the time needed for completion.

‍

Several key considerations impact title work across Pennsylvania:

‍

1. General Difficulty of Title - Varies significantly by region due to historical land use patterns
2. Legal Issues - Past court decisions on local or regional issues can change ownership determinations
3. Coal Concerns - Shallow coal formations in the Appalachian Basin impact drill site locations
4. Landman Availability - A local landman base affects project startup times and costs

‍

Regional Analysis: The Seven Distinct Title Zones of Pennsylvania

‍

Dudley Land Company has identified seven distinct title zones across Pennsylvania, each with unique characteristics that impact title work complexity, timing, and cost.

‍

Southwestern PA (Washington/Greene/Fayette)

‍

This region presents moderate historical title challenges, with recent oil and gas activity creating robust lease chains that can extend completion times. Legal interpretations of reservations here often mirror those in West Virginia.

‍

Example: A reservation of 'one-eighth of oil and gas' is usually interpreted as a royalty reservation. The surface owner retains executive rights to lease and receive bonuses.

Coal production history drastically increases drill site title turn-around times due to the necessity of pad site location waivers from active coal lease owners.

‍

While local landmen are generally available due to proximity to Pittsburgh, high demand during natural gas price spikes can create staffing challenges.

‍

Southern PA (Somerset/Bedford/Cambria/Blair)

‍

Title work in this region is relatively straightforward, with "Being Clauses" in documents providing clear references to sources of title. Limited historical production means less complex assignment chains. Coal concerns still exist but decrease moving eastward.

‍

Local landmen can be difficult to quickly locate due to limited current activity, often requiring travel from Pittsburgh, which adds to project costs.

‍

Central Western PA
(Butler/Clarion/Jefferson/Armstrong/Indiana/Clearfield/Westmoreland)

‍

Title difficulty is moderate here but can increase with old production history. A significant legal consideration in this region relates to historical gas rights.

Due to old production in this region, 'Free Gas' is prevalent here. Many old leases allowed the landowner to use gas produced from shallow low-pressure formations for home use.

‍

Additional challenges include convoluted old oil and gas chains that require production checks to verify if old leases remain active. The prevalence of coal production increases drill site title completion times. However, landman availability is favorable due to the region's proximity to Pittsburgh and local landmen from historical production activities.

‍

Allegheny County

‍

As an urban epicenter, this county presents difficult title challenges, particularly with surface-related ownership issues.

‍

Title traps are almost always surface-related due to ownership frequently changing hands. Title around rivers can become incredibly complex.

‍

Heavy historical coal production, including longwall mining, creates drilling concerns that require Department of Environmental Protection maps. 

‍

While landmen are generally available due to the population center, high demand during gas price spikes can create staffing challenges.

‍

Northwestern PA (Erie/Crawford/Mercer/Venango/Lawrence/Beaver)

‍

This region offers some of the easiest title work in Pennsylvania, with straightforward historical records and limited production activity. Notably, this is not historically a coal-producing zone, which simplifies the process considerably.

‍

Landman availability varies, with good access in the southern areas near Pittsburgh but more challenges in the northern counties where travel from Eastern Ohio or Pittsburgh is often required.

‍

Northern PA (Warren/McKean/Potter/Forest/Elk/Cameron)

‍

Our team has identified this region as having the most difficult title in the state.

This area was mostly owned by logging companies from the late 1800's through the 1920's. During this time the tracts of land were extremely large. After the timber was processed, smaller tracts were subdivided from the parent parcels. These smaller tracts had extremely poor legal descriptions and their locations are many times unable to be found in the parent parcel.

‍

The main issue is identifying tracts of land based on their respective legal descriptions, often requiring outside mapping resources that are not readily available. There are virtually no oil and gas landmen in this region, necessitating relocation of personnel and increased accommodation expenses.

‍

Northeastern PA (Tioga/Bradford/Susquehanna/Clinton/Lycoming/Sullivan/ Wyoming/Lackawanna/Luzerne/Columbia/Centre)

‍

Title difficulty ranges from easy to moderate, with robust lease chains from recent activity potentially extending completion times. The most significant legal consideration in this region is a process known as "Title Washing.”

Title Washing is a legal mechanism in PA that is frequently associated with this region where a tax sale can operate to recombine a tract that had severed surface and mineral estates. It requires a tax sale for delinquent taxes on surface lands that have not been developed. Once sold, oil/gas/minerals are recombined with the surface estate.

‍

Landman availability has declined since peak activity in the early 2010s, with local resources available in urban centers like State College, Williamsport, and Scranton for smaller projects. Larger projects may require relocating landmen with associated accommodation costs.

‍

Time Estimates: Setting Realistic Client Expectations

‍

Dudley Land Company's experience allows for data-driven estimates of completion times across the different regions:

These time estimates provide the foundation for accurate cost projections, helping clients plan their projects with greater confidence.

‍

Making the Complex Simple: The Dudley Advantage

‍

By understanding the nuanced regional variations in Pennsylvania title work, Dudley Land Company transforms a potentially complicated process into a manageable, predictable project. Our thorough understanding of:

‍

• Regional title difficulty variations
• Legal precedents that impact ownership determinations
• Coal production history and its impact on drilling locations
• Landman availability and associated cost implications

‍

allows us to provide clients with accurate time and cost estimations tailored to their specific project locations.

‍

Take the Next Step in Securing Accurate Title Work

‍

Don't let Pennsylvania's complex regional title variations derail your project timeline or budget. Contact Dudley Land Company today to benefit from our unmatched regional expertise and commitment to making a complicated process simple.

‍

Our team of experienced professionals will provide you with a detailed assessment of your specific project requirements, accurate time and cost estimates, and a clear path forward.